The architect behind The Buccaneers dissects the finale, exploring Nan's decision and delving into the maternal drama

By M Muzamil Shami

Katherine Jakeways provides insights into the Season 1 finale of the Apple TV+ drama, addressing our most pressing questions.

Caution: This content includes spoilers pertaining to the concluding episode of The Buccaneers Season 1, titled "Wedding of the Season."

It's not quite the fairy-tale ending we anticipated.

Last Wednesday marked the surprising conclusion of the inaugural season of The Buccaneers, adapted from Edith Wharton's last, incomplete novel. Nan (Kristine Forseth), determined to elope with Guy (Matthew Broome), found herself on the brink of abandoning Theo, Duke of Tintagel (Guy Remmers), at the altar. However, a sudden realization of her sister Jinny's (Imogen Waterhouse) dire situation in an abusive marriage led Nan to make a selfless choice. She sacrificed her own shot at happiness by arranging for Jinny to escape with Guy instead.

Photograph of Kristine Froseth in the Apple TV+ series 'The Buccaneers'

In the meantime, Richard (played by Josh Dylan) and Conchita (portrayed by Alisha Boe) made a firm decision to carve out a life on their own terms, disregarding family wealth. Their plans, however, took an unexpected turn when Richard's father, Lord Brightlingsea, was revealed to be terminally ill. Meanwhile, Mabel (Josie Totah), after considering a marriage proposal from a man, opted to embrace the prospect of a life with Honoria (Mia Threapleton). The concluding moments of the show unveiled a surprising revelation from Mrs. St. George (Christina Hendricks), who not only knew the true identity of Nan's biological mother but also disclosed that the woman was present in the crowd at Nan's wedding.

While AppleTV+ has not yet confirmed a second season for The Buccaneers, the finale has left viewers with numerous unanswered questions. In our quest for answers, we reached out to creator Katherine Jakeways to delve into Mabel's future, Nan's sacrifice, and the potential revelation of the ultimate secret regarding Nan's mother.

Kristine Froseth and Matthew Broome featured in 'The Buccaneers'. Image: APPLE TV+

ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Despite her mother's denial of her true identity, Mabel is determined to embark on her own romantic journey. If a second season is in the cards, can we anticipate that it will bring challenges more complex than she is prepared for?

KATHERINE JAKEWAYS: 

The dynamics of all the relationships in the show are more intricate than initially apparent. Our intention with Mabel and Honoria's relationship was to create a clandestine connection, distinct from the others in the show, characterized by additional hurdles that introduce unique challenges. Unlike the other couples, they can't openly dance before friends, receive rings, throw parties, or have a grand wedding to declare their love. From the outset, we were resolute about infusing their relationship with joy, romance, and authenticity comparable to any other in the show. Our aim was to avoid portraying it as a sorrowful affair confined to secrecy and sadness. Instead, we wanted to showcase moments of laughter, love, and shared happiness between them. The final scene on the balcony, where Honoria effectively says "I do" while holding a bouquet of flowers, captures a whimsical dance that symbolizes their happy ending, perhaps even more so than any other character in the series. While there's no indication of a second season at this point, the future of Mabel and Honoria's love remains uncertain, and we're left to ponder how it might impact their families. Regardless, our hope is that they find lasting happiness together.

Richard and Conchita decide to embark on separate journeys despite their limited financial resources. What possible consequences might result from this choice?

There are various possible outcomes for their future. One optimistic scenario envisions them successfully making a grand escape from their family, residing on a beach without financial burdens or responsibilities. However, the narrative takes a turn in episode 8 when he learns about his father's impending death. If this event transpires, they may find themselves compelled to assume the roles of Lord and Lady Brightlingsea, introducing complications to their envisioned plan. Their path forward might not be as smooth as they had hoped.

      Photograph of Guy Remmers in 'The Buccaneers' on APPLE TV+

With Nan's assistance, Jinny manages to escape, but there's a lingering sense of danger. How much should we worry about her well-being as she departs in the carriage?

James is in close pursuit, isn't he? Swiftly following her, he's a determined individual who won't easily concede. He's undoubtedly keen to discover her whereabouts. Despite a sigh of relief and the reassuring presence of Guy Thwarte by her side, navigating this situation won't be without its challenges. Complicating matters, Jinny is carrying James' child—a circumstance that, in that era, would likely be deemed as a breach for a woman to abscond with a child, whether unborn or born, that rightfully belonged to her husband. She faces threats not only from the law and authorities but also from James himself. However, with Guy Thwarte holding those coveted boat tickets, there's hope for their successful escape.

Nan unmistakably harbors deep affection for Guy, yet she chooses to marry Theo to assist her sister. Assuming the story unfolds further, it seems likely that this love triangle will persist. Despite this, how will Nan's evident feelings for both men further complicate her life?

We were deeply invested in crafting a genuine and realistic romantic dilemma for her, steering away from the love triangle presented in the book. In the original text, the Duke character was portrayed as a far less suitable choice for her, evident from the beginning as someone incompatible with her happiness. Our aim was to transform it into a sincere decision between two viable options for her at different points in time. Throughout the process, discussions arose about who sided with Team Guy and who with Team Theo.

Nan's life is inherently complex, further complicated by her newfound duty to her husband, a commitment that binds her for life as she married a Duke. The dowager, keen on preserving the institution, will ensure Nan adheres to her obligations without causing harm. While Nan harbors feelings for Theo, and he is not inherently cruel or an unsuitable choice, it's evident that her true affections lie elsewhere. The path ahead for Nan seems challenging, yet she has made a decision integral to her identity — choosing her sister. Will it be Guy or Theo? The answer is no. When push comes to shove, Nan instinctively chooses Jinny, despite their strained relationship and past betrayals. It wasn't merely a decision; it was a fundamental choice aligned with who she is at her core.

     Christina Hendricks stars in 'The Buccaneers' on Apple TV+

We conclude with the revelation that Nan's biological mother is present at the wedding. Do you all recognize her? Would her identity remain a mystery as you move ahead?

We are aware of her identity. It would be negligent of us not to discuss the identity of Nan's mother. Therefore, it's a matter that might or might not be disclosed in the future, but we remain hopeful.