India and France Clash Over Rafale Jet Failures in Pakistan Conflict

      India’s Rafale jets underperformed during the war with Pakistan, sparking global debate

India and France Clash Over Rafale Jet Failures in Pakistan Conflict

​​By M Muzamil Shami - May 30, 2025

Introduction:

The recent Indo-Pak conflict has cast a spotlight on the performance of India's French-made Dassault Rafale fighter jets, leading to a diplomatic rift between India and France. The unexpected underperformance of these advanced aircraft against Pakistan's Chinese-supplied PL-15 missiles has raised questions about the efficacy of Western defense technology and India's military preparedness.

Rafale Jets Under Scrutiny:

During the conflict, India's Rafale jets were reportedly outmaneuvered by Pakistan's J-10C fighters equipped with PL-15E beyond-visual-range (BVR) missiles. Reports suggest that up to three Rafales were shot down, leading to concerns about the aircraft's combat capabilities. This has prompted Indonesia, a prospective Rafale buyer, to audit its $8.1 billion deal with Dassault Aviation, reflecting broader apprehensions about the jet's performance.

France Attributes Failures to Indian Maintenance:

In response to the criticism, France has suggested that the Rafale's underperformance was due to India's maintenance practices and pilot training deficiencies. French officials have requested access to India's Rafale fleet for inspection, but India has denied this request, fearing that France aims to deflect blame onto the Indian Air Force (IAF).

IAF's Operational Challenges:

The IAF has been grappling with a pilot shortage, with a deficit increasing from 486 in 2015 to 596 in 2021. Efforts to induct 222 trainee pilots annually between 2016 and 2021 fell short, exacerbating the issue. Additionally, delays in procuring and maintaining trainer aircraft like the Pilatus PC-7 Mk-II have hindered pilot training, affecting overall combat readiness.

READ MORE

Chinese J-10C Jets Outshine Indian Rafales in Kashmir Skirmish

PL-15 Missile's Impact:

The PL-15 missile, developed by China, has demonstrated significant capabilities in the conflict. With a range of approximately 145 km in its export version, the missile's performance has raised concerns about the technological edge of Western aircraft like the Rafale. The successful deployment of the PL-15 by Pakistan underscores the evolving dynamics of air combat in the region.

Source Code Access Denied:

A significant point of contention is Dassault's refusal to share the Rafale's source code with India. This limitation hampers India's ability to perform comprehensive maintenance and integrate indigenous systems, leading to operational challenges. The lack of access has fueled debates about the terms of defense deals and the importance of technological autonomy.

Global Repercussions:

The Rafale's performance issues have implications beyond India. Indonesia's reconsideration of its Rafale purchase reflects a broader skepticism among potential buyers. The incident also highlights the growing competitiveness of Chinese defense technology, as evidenced by the PL-15's effectiveness.

Conclusion:

The Rafale controversy underscores the need for India to reassess its defense procurement strategies, emphasizing the importance of operational readiness, technological autonomy, and strategic partnerships. As global defense dynamics shift, nations must balance the allure of advanced foreign technology with the imperatives of self-reliance and adaptability.

FAQs:

1. Why did India's Rafale jets underperform against Pakistan?
The underperformance is attributed to a combination of factors, including maintenance issues, pilot training deficiencies, and the advanced capabilities of Pakistan's PL-15 missiles.

2. What is the PL-15 missile?
The PL-15 is a Chinese-developed beyond-visual-range air-to-air missile with a range of approximately 145 km in its export version, used effectively by Pakistan during the conflict.

3. Why is access to the Rafale's source code important for India?
Access to the source code would allow India to perform in-depth maintenance, integrate indigenous systems, and ensure operational flexibility, which is currently limited.

4. How has Indonesia responded to the Rafale's performance issues?
Indonesia has initiated an audit of its Rafale purchase deal, reflecting concerns about the aircraft's combat effectiveness following reports from the Indo-Pak conflict.

Join the Discussion:
Should India prioritize indigenous defense development over foreign acquisitions? Share your thoughts on the future of India's military strategy.

Stay Informed:
Follow us for the latest updates on global defense news and strategic analyses.